Bang for the Buck
 

04/15/2002

I don't think I'll be joining the Redline Collector's Club. I did the math and for $24.99 a year membership plus a dozen or so exclusives at $12-20 each, I think I would rather stay married. I understand those first two Camaros are really nice; chrome plated, racing stripes, redline real riders and the club logo on the doors. But you know, I've got Camaros already, and most of them are really nice, too. I've even got a really nice chrome plated model with real riders that came in the Collectibles line. I suppose, if I wanted to, I could apply some racing stripe decals and redline stickers to the tires, but that sounds like more work than I'm in the mood to do.

I've always been of two minds about limited editions anyway. They started appearing right about the time i got into collecting, though on a much more modest scale than what we see now. Typical of the LE's back then was the Old Number 5 in yellow, with yellow 6-spoke Pro-Circuit wheels. It was Treasure Hunt quality, limited to 7000 and retailed for about $8-10. I liked the look of it but thought the price was a bit steep to pay for fresh paint and different wheels. I did buy the black Smokey Yunick 55 Chevy because I didn't have the casting, and it looked much better than the then current regular issue. I traded a Johnny Lightning Club exclusive (I forget which one) for the Carrol Shelby silver Cobra, and I found a few promotionals like the Spam Camaro, the Coronet Funny Car, and the Aquafresh Thunderstreak at a thrift store for a quarter each. I was given a few Hiway Haulers, and I found a few more, and I liked the first Dolly Madison set (McKee Baking) enough to pay $10 at a toy show. But by and large, I let the limited edition scene pass me by. Over time, the prices of limiteds didn't creep up, they zoomed. And the number of limiteds put out each year skyrocketed along with the prices. I watched my fellow collectors buy cereal, laundry detergent, and very bad fish sticks, just to get a limited edition and keep their collections "complete'. Of course, 1996 saw the release of the VW Drag Bus, a casting designed specifically to be used in limited editions. Bus LE's multiplied like rabbits, (a little VW humor) and ranged in price from $20-60. Some of the LE's that came out could most charitably be described as 'Butt-ugly", and I couldn't imagine anyone wanting to be seen driving a 1:1 version on the street, but if you were a completist, you had to have it or you were a complete failure as a collector. About this same time, I began to hear the first complaints of limited edition burn-out.

Meanwhile, there was a lot of good 1:64 diecast coming out. Mattel introduced the 100% Collectibles line. RC/Ertl began producing some incredibly detailed cars in 1:64. Johnny Lightning continued to release great all-metal castings, many with real rubber tires, for $3-5. Given the choice of paying $15-20 or more for a casting I already had, just with different paint and wheels, or paying $3-10 for a new casting with way more detail than what is still, essentially, a $1 toy car at heart, I voted with my dollars for where I would get the most bang for the buck.

But getting back to the Redline Club, I gotta admit a lot of things sound intriguing: the return of spectraflame paints, the re-introduction of redline wheels with delrine bearings, and even the possibility of resurrecting some old castings. I am amused that the delrine wheels, designed to be particularly fast on the track, are going to be used primarily on vehicles that most people will never take out of the package for fear of destroying the investment value. I don't really worry about missing any castings brought back from the dead. Diecast toolings are too expensive to use only once. Note all the supposedly $30 Legends castings now turning up in $8 100% Collectibles boxes. And paint is paint. I can live without spectraflame if it is priced beyond my interest. I think the only things I will really miss from the Redline Club are the interviews and sneak peeks. Of course, the peeks become a moot point as soon as the real ting is released, and info has a way of getting around regardless of the exclusivity of the source. My collection will keep growing in whatever direction I choose, club or no club. In fact, I think I'm going to be in the game long after most holders of those precious first Camaros have spent themselves right out.

Keep it in scale.

 
The Southern Gent--Raymond McKee
 
Have you missed any Keep It In Scale Articles? Click Here